Shock revelations have emerged that William Tyrrell was reported missing years before he disappeared on September 12, 2024.
William, who was three-years-old when he vanished more than 10 years ago, had been taken into hiding two years earlier by his grandmother, Natalie Collins.
Ms Collins said she was behind his first disappearance after a court ordered him be taken from his biological parents – her son Brendan Collins and Karlie Tyrrell.
‘So I hid them,’ Ms Collins told news.com.au’s podcast Witness: William Tyrrell.
‘I hid them for three months after I knew (NSW government officials) were going to take William… I arranged it all.’
William was just seven months old in February 2012 when the court ordered that be taken from his biological parents.
The Department of Family and Community Services was concerned about domestic violence and substance abuse within the boy’s family, a court heard.
William’s mother was at the hearing and so knew her son was going to be placed under the parental responsibility of a NSW government minister.

+4
View gallery
The mystery of William Tyrrell (pictured) has had another shocking twist, with his biological grandmother revealing that his disappearance on September 12, 2014 was not the first

+4
View gallery
William, who was three-years-old when he was last seen more than 10 years ago, had also been taken into hiding more than two years earlier by his grandmother, Natalie Collins (pictured)
But when the authorities arrived to collect William from her home that afternoon, the family had gone into hiding with Ms Collins, who said she was the ‘mastermind’ of the disappearance.
A police strike force called Duncraig was set up to find William, and after many failures and wrong turns, it did find him later in 2012, and the boy was placed with foster parents.
That couple, which can’t be identified for legal reasons, reported him missing in 2014.
William has never been seen since and no one has been charged over the disappearance.
The second disappearance a decade ago led to the creation of strike force Rosann.
Ms Collins said given William’s second disappearance, the NSW government ‘didn’t do their job properly’ and should not have taken him from his biological family.
She said ‘this shouldn’t happen these days with foster care children … I’ve got one son in rehab, I’ve got one in jail and my family has been stuffed up.
‘I lost my son and I lost myself on the way.’
The podcast also spoke to a government officer who was there when William was taken from his mother before being placed with his foster parents.
He also wonders is taking William from Ms Tyrrell was the right choice.
‘We take kids off … families all the time,’ the man, who asked to remain anonymous, said, breaking down in tears. ‘You do it. It is part of the job.

+4
View gallery
The three-year-old was last seen playing hide and seek with his sister outside this house before his disappearance
‘The thing I get upset about is … we took William off Karlie to protect him. I can still see myself walking into that bloody unit … And there was William, on the floor.
‘And I just think … did we do the right thing? Would he still be alive? Maybe.’
The man said he still regularly thinks about William Tyrrell. ‘Not day to day, but it does affect me. Because it keeps coming back.’
An inquest into William’s suspected death will resume in November.
A Department of Communities and Justice spokesperson told Daily Mail Australia that ‘No comment will be given in relation to the ongoing coronial investigation into the disappearance and suspected death of William Tyrrell.’
News
‘I GAVE IT A CRACK’ — FINAL MESSAGE FROM CANCER PIONEER Richard Scolyer MOVES AUSTRALIA AS NATION MOURNS AT 59
My fellow Australians, I pen this letter as a final goodbye to all those I have had the immense privilege of loving, sharing life’s adventures with, working alongside and meeting during what can only be described as a life filled…
‘ONE OF BRITAIN’S MOST HAUNTING UNSOLVED NIGHTMARES’ — NETFLIX’S 3-PART TRUE CRIME SERIES REOPENS THE CASE THAT SHOOK THE NATION AND LEFT A FAMILY FOREVER CHANGED
netflix has just dropped all three episodes of its latest true crime series, The Witness, a dramatisation of the 1992 murder of mother-of-one Rachel Nickell. The three-part series is also based on Rachel’s son, Alex Hanscombe’s memoir, Letting Go. Alex was just aged…
‘EVERYTHING WE THOUGHT WE KNEW WAS WRONG’ — NETFLIX’S THE WITNESS REOPENS BRITAIN’S MOST HAUNTING UNSOLVED-THEN-SOLVED MUR-DER CASE
The Witness has landed on Netflix, a true crime drama chronicling an investigation that stretched across 10 years. In July 1992, Rachel Nickell was fatally stabbed on Wimbledon Common with her two-year-old son Alex as the sole witness. Today, Thursday, June 4, Netflix has unveiled…
‘YOU WON’T TRUST A SINGLE CHARACTER’ — NETFLIX’S NEW RESORT MYSTERY IS BEING COMPARED TO THE WHITE LOTUS, BUT FANS SAY THE TWISTS ARE EVEN MORE SH0CKING
Counting down the days until The White Lotus returns? Netflix might just have your next obsession. Oasis is the sun-drenched crime series arriving later this month that looks seriously good. Set at an exclusive luxury resort, it’s all sunshine, parties and beaches until a mysterious…
‘I STARTED ONE EPISODE AND FINISHED THE WHOLE SEASON’ — NETFLIX’S MOST UNDERRATED CRIME MASTERPIECE IS BACK AND FANS CAN’T STOP TALKING ABOUT IT
Back in 2024, Netflix dropped the first season of Crooks, a German-language crime thriller. The show followed Charly (Frederick Lau) who is forced to travel around Europe in order to rescue his kidnapped family following a disastrous heist job. The second season,…
‘WE THOUGHT THE WORST WAS OVER’ — HEARTBROKEN FAMILY CONFRONTED WITH SH0CKING NEW DISCOVERY AFTER MISSING SCIENTIST’S B0DY WAS FOUND
The body of a missing nuclear lab worker who vanished last year was reportedly found “skeletonized” with a gunshot to her skull in a national forest in New Mexico. Melissa Casias’ decaying body was found in a remote part of the Carson…
End of content
No more pages to load