ABC has officially renewed American Idol for Season 24, marking the long-running singing competition’s ninth season since its revival on the network. While the announcement has excited fans of the show, it arrives amid growing speculation that judge Carrie Underwood may not be returning for another season.

The network shared the news in a celebratory Instagram post that read, “Dim the lights… here we go. #AmericanIdol is coming back for another season!”—a nod to host Ryan Seacrest’s iconic catchphrase uttered before elimination results are revealed. The post also confirmed that online auditions are now open, continuing the show’s tradition of seeking out vocal talent from across the country.

Carrie Underwood, who joined the judging panel this season in place of longtime judge Katy Perry, has faced a mix of reactions from viewers. Some fans appreciated the country superstar’s fresh perspective, while others criticized the judges—Carrie, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan—for offering what they felt was overly positive and non-critical feedback throughout the season.

Behind the scenes, it’s been reported that Carrie has expressed discomfort with some aspects of the judging process, particularly the eliminations. Sources close to production say she has struggled with the idea of being perceived as “mean” and doesn’t enjoy having to critique contestants harshly—leading many to believe she may opt out of returning in Season 24.

Still, fans flooded the comments section of ABC’s announcement post with pleas for Carrie, Luke, and Lionel to return, signaling that many have embraced this season’s panel despite the criticism.

Season 23 of American Idol has offered its usual blend of emotional storytelling and powerhouse performances, including standout finalists like Jamal Roberts, Breanna Nix, and John Foster—each carving out unique musical journeys. While the show may not produce mega-stars like Carrie herself or Kelly Clarkson in its current format, it continues to serve as a family-friendly showcase of talent and inspiration.

As the competition heads toward its highly anticipated finale, the focus remains on the contestants’ stories and vocal growth—reminding fans that the heart of American Idol has always been about discovering new voices and celebrating dreams.

Whether Carrie Underwood returns or not, the show’s renewal is a clear sign that American Idol remains a beloved piece of television, capable of evolving with the times while holding onto its core appeal. And as one generation of idols makes way for the next, one thing is certain: American Idol isn’t going anywhere anytime soon.