Farewell to Pauline Collins: The Iconic Star Who Followed Her Own Path
Pauline Collins, one of Britain’s most recognisable and respected actresses, died yesterday at the age of 85 after living with Parkinson’s disease. Loved by generations of television and theatre audiences, Collins became a fixture of British popular culture through a career defined as much by her remarkable performances as by her refusal to stay in any one place for too long.
To the wider world, she will forever be Shirley Valentine, the warm, witty and quietly yearning Liverpool housewife whose mid-life awakening captivated millions. The role, which began as a one-woman play in London before transferring triumphantly to Broadway, showcased Collins at her most powerful: empathetic, funny, devastatingly honest, and able to hold an audience in the palm of her hand with nothing but her voice, her face, and Willy Russell’s monologue-driven script. The 1989 film adaptation cemented her place in screen history, though her casting was far from guaranteed. Even Cher, fresh off an Oscar win and hungry for the part, was in serious contention. Collins later recalled that director Lewis Gilbert insisted the film would not be made without her, a decision that, for many admirers, proved both brave and entirely correct.
Yet for all the global acclaim that came with Shirley Valentine, Collins’s career could have followed an entirely different trajectory. Her professional life was marked by a bold pattern of leaving popular projects at their peak, driven not by restlessness but by a conviction that change was essential to her creative spirit. She once famously described herself as “a bolter,” explaining, “I’m not giving up. I love change. I want to do different things.”
That instinct surfaced early on. After just two series on Upstairs, Downstairs, where she played the spirited, flirtatious maid Sarah, Collins made the unexpected decision to walk away from the show. The set of that series was also where she met her husband, actor John Alderton, forming a partnership that would become one of the most steady, admired relationships in British entertainment. Their connection lasted decades, a rarity in a field known for its rapid turnover of both fame and relationships.
Collins’s brief encounter with Doctor Who remains another example of her distinctive career choices. She appeared in a 1967 episode of the beloved sci-fi series and was quickly offered the opportunity to become one of the Doctor’s earliest companions. For most young actors, such a role would have promised a surge in visibility and security. For Collins, the thought of a 39-episode contract was something closer to misery. She later said the idea of such a long commitment felt like being “trapped forever,” and she politely declined. The decision, in hindsight, became one of the defining what-ifs of British television history.
Her desire for fresh experiences surfaced yet again after the first series of The Liver Birds. Despite the sitcom’s warm reception and its eventual status as a classic of its era, Collins chose to move on, seeking new horizons rather than settling into something predictable. That pattern of stepping away just as things took off might have halted another actor’s momentum. Instead, it became part of Collins’s allure, marking her as someone who followed a personal compass rather than the traditional map to fame.
The path she built led her from stage to screen and back again, gathering admirers at every turn. Her performance in the stage version of Shirley Valentine stunned critics and audiences on both sides of the Atlantic, yet even with that history, some film producers doubted whether she should carry the lead role on screen. That hesitation is almost unthinkable in retrospect, but Collins never resented the uncertainty. She understood the industry’s caution but remained quietly confident. When Gilbert refused to proceed without her, it was a moment of affirmation she would reference with gratitude.
Collins’s death marks the end of a career that defied expectation at nearly every stage. She rejected complacency, avoided typecasting, and treated each role as something finite, something to embrace fully and then release when the time came. Her choices may have cost her certain opportunities, but they also gave Britain one of its most distinctive and authentic performers.
Her legacy lives on through the characters she embodied, the risks she took, and the audiences she moved. Shirley Valentine might be the role that defined her, but Pauline Collins was always so much more: a clear-eyed, courageous artist who refused to let success become a cage, and who trusted her own instincts above all else.
