Kevin Costner’s ‘The First Christmas’: A Reverent Nativity Retelling That’s Moving Viewers to Tears

In a holiday lineup often dominated by lighthearted rom-coms and animated classics, Kevin Costner Presents: The First Christmas has emerged as an unexpected standout, captivating audiences with its gritty, historically grounded portrayal of the Nativity story. The two-hour ABC special, which premiered on December 9, 2025, and was rebroadcast on December 20, has been hailed by viewers as “magnificent,” “life-changing,” and a profound reminder of the season’s true meaning.

masslive.com

Hosted and narrated by Kevin Costner, the program strips away sentimental traditions to reveal the raw human struggles of Mary and Joseph amid political oppression under Herod. Filmed in Morocco for authentic desert landscapes, dramatic reenactments—featuring Gia Rose Patel as Mary and Ethan Thorne as Joseph—bring Bethlehem to life, interspersed with insights from theologians and historians. Costner, drawing from his childhood church plays, shares personal reflections, urging viewers to “keep Christ in Christmas.”

americamagazine.org

christiandaily.com

Directed by David L. Cunningham, the special explores hardships like Mary’s societal judgment, the taxing journey, and dangers from Herod’s regime, while staying faithful to Scripture. Reviews praise its educational depth and emotional resonance: “A wonderful, educational experience,” one IMDb user wrote, noting historical insights valuable even for non-believers. Families report watching in hushed silence, tears flowing as ancient events unfold vividly. Churches encouraged replays, and social media buzzes with calls for more faith-based programming.

decider.com

abc.com

Now streaming on Hulu and Disney+, this revelation transcends typical holiday fare, offering inspiration in turbulent times. Costner didn’t just retell the Christmas story—he resurrected its power to unite and heal.