The day marked the dramatic conclusion of American Idol Season 23, and though Jamal Roberts walked away with the crown, it’s runner-up John Foster who continues to dominate headlines — and hearts — following a whirlwind finale night that shattered voting records.

A Historic Finale, A Surprising Result

This year’s Idol finale brought in over 26 million votes, making it the most-voted season end in recent memory — more than double the total from last season. Going into the final results, many believed 18-year-old John Foster from Louisiana was the likely winner, thanks to his powerful performances, fan momentum, and viral original song. Yet, in a surprising turn, he placed second — igniting passionate debates and a flood of support across social media.

John Foster: A Voice That Struck a National Chord

Throughout the season, Foster became a fan favorite for his authentic country sound, heartfelt lyrics, and genuine personality. His original song — performed live during the competition — resonated far beyond the show, gaining widespread praise and streaming traction.

Viewers connected not just to his voice, but to the raw storytelling and humble energy he brought to every performance. To many, Foster was the soul of Season 23.

The Finale Sparked Buzz — and Backlash

While the live finale dazzled with stunning visuals and show-stopping performances, not all fans walked away content. A particular moment — where Foster’s expression subtly changed just before the winner was named — went viral, prompting speculation and frustration from some corners of the internet.

Paired with comments from past contestants about production dynamics, the finale reignited conversation about fairness and transparency — with Foster once again at the center of it all.

Foster Responds with Grace and Gratitude

Rather than dwell on the loss, Foster took to Facebook with a message that melted hearts and inspired even more devotion from his fanbase. In his post, he wrote:

“Man, what a true blessing to share this Idol stage with so many incredible heroes, both new faces and legends. I’m beyond thankful, and I can’t wait to keep making music for y’all as long as the good Lord lets me. Thank you from the bottom of my heart – times a million.”

The response was instant. Fans flooded the comments calling him “the people’s champ” and “the real winner,” with many vowing to follow his career long after Idol.

Watch Again: Who Had the True Winning Performance?

Still unsure who really stole the show? The final performances from both John Foster and Jamal Roberts are available below — watch them side-by-side and decide who truly owned the Season 23 stage.

Jamal Roberts Performane: