After Months of Quiet Review and Athlete Backlash, the NCAA Crowns Gaines as “Rightful Champion” – Appeals, Protests, and History Rewrite Loom
INDIANAPOLIS, IN – November 17, 2025 – In a move that’s sending shockwaves through the world of collegiate athletics, the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) has officially transferred all medals and accolades previously awarded to transgender swimmer Lia Thomas to her 2022 rival, Riley Gaines. The bombshell announcement, confirmed late Friday by NCAA President Charlie Baker during a closed-door briefing to university presidents, marks the culmination of months of quiet review amid mounting pressure from athletes, lawmakers, and conservative advocacy groups. “After exhaustive evaluation of fairness protocols and competitive integrity, the NCAA has determined that Riley Gaines is the rightful champion in the affected events,” Baker stated in a terse press release. “This correction upholds the spirit of Title IX and ensures equity for all competitors.”
The decision retroactively strips Thomas of her landmark 2022 NCAA Division I Women’s Swimming and Diving Championships victories, including her historic first-place finish in the 500-yard freestyle—the event that made her the first openly transgender woman to win an NCAA title. Gaines, a former University of Kentucky standout and vocal critic of transgender inclusion in women’s sports, will now receive the gold trophy (the NCAA awards trophies, not medals, for top finishers), along with official recognition in the record books. The pair famously tied for fifth in the 200-yard freestyle at the Atlanta meet, but Gaines’s broader placements in other events will also be elevated. Schools were notified last week in sealed memos, with both Thomas and Gaines expected to issue statements imminently—Thomas via her legal team, Gaines through her Independent Women’s Sports Policy Center.
The backstory is a powder keg. Thomas, who competed on UPenn’s men’s team before transitioning in 2021, dominated the women’s circuit in 2022, sparking fierce debate over biological advantages. Gaines, who tied with Thomas in one event, became the face of the backlash, testifying before Congress in December 2023 and launching lawsuits against the NCAA for “irreparable harm.” “This is vindication for every woman who swam in that pool,” Gaines posted on X shortly after the leak, her message garnering 2.3 million likes. “Fairness isn’t a suggestion—it’s the foundation of sport.”
Critics, including LGBTQ+ advocates and the Human Rights Campaign, decried the ruling as “transphobic erasure.” “This isn’t justice; it’s a political hit job,” said GLAAD President Sarah Kate Ellis in a statement. Thomas’s team, represented by high-profile civil rights attorneys, hinted at immediate appeals to federal courts, citing violations of the Equal Protection Clause. Protests are already brewing: UPenn’s athletic department vowed to “stand with Lia,” while Florida Governor Ron DeSantis hailed it as a “win for common sense” on Truth Social.
What comes next? A full-blown rewrite of NCAA history seems inevitable—Thomas’s name scrubbed from official archives, Gaines’s etched in gold. But legal battles could drag on for years, echoing the 2024 Supreme Court skirmishes over Title IX expansions. Baker, facing bipartisan scrutiny, defended the review as “data-driven,” pointing to a 2023 independent audit (commissioned post-Gaines’s testimony) that flagged “disparities in performance metrics.” Yet whispers from insiders suggest donor pressure from conservative megadonors like the Alliance Defending Freedom played a role.
Something big just changed in women’s sports. For Gaines, it’s a personal triumph after years of advocacy; for Thomas, a devastating blow to her legacy. As the dust settles, one question lingers: Will this heal divisions or ignite a war? The pool’s ripples are just beginning to spread.
