In a stunning shakeup that has set the cable news world ablaze, Fox News announced on June 9, 2025, that Sandra Smith is replacing Jessica Tarlov as a co-host on The Five, pairing her with Greg Gutfeld in a move that’s already reshaping the show’s dynamic. The revelation, dropped during a live segment, sent shockwaves through viewers and insiders, with social media erupting (#TheFiveShakeup). Is this Gutfeld’s bold vision to refresh the top-rated show, or a risky gamble that could alienate fans?

Smith, a seasoned journalist known for her sharp reporting on America Reports, brings a measured, business-savvy tone to the panel, joining Gutfeld, Jesse Watters, Dana Perino, and Harold Ford Jr. Sources suggest Gutfeld, whose influence has soared with Gutfeld! leading late-night ratings, pushed for Smith to add “fresh energy” (Story News). Her debut on June 9 sparked mixed reactions: fans on X praised her as “classy and smart” (@PatriotNewsHQ), while others mourned Tarlov’s exit, calling her the “voice we needed” (@FreedomWatch2025).

Tarlov, the show’s liberal firebrand since 2017, reportedly clashed with Gutfeld over issues like Trump’s tariffs, fueling speculation of tension. Her absence coincided with a maternity leave in April 2025, but Fox confirmed she’ll transition to a new role, possibly a solo segment (News Today 21). Critics argue Gutfeld’s move tilts The Five further right, risking its balance, while supporters see Smith’s diplomacy complementing his humor. Will this duo redefine the show, or has Fox lost its edge?