Amid Debate on Falling Holiday Meal Prices, Hosts Cite Trump Data – But Compagno’s North Pole Source Sparks Laughter and Confusion on the Air
A routine Fox & Friends segment on Thanksgiving dinner costs took an unexpected – and utterly baffling – turn toward the North Pole Thursday morning, as co-host Emily Compagno revealed that Santa Claus himself had confided in her about a “high sense of optimism he hasn’t seen for a long time.” The bizarre pivot came during a discussion of a Wells Fargo report showing a 4.5% drop in average holiday meal prices from last year, bringing the cost for a traditional spread for 10 down to $63.23 – the lowest since 2021. While the hosts debated whether Americans are feeling real relief amid economic pressures, Compagno’s invocation of St. Nick left her co-hosts chuckling and viewers scratching their heads, transforming a policy chat into a surreal holiday fever dream.
The segment, part of Fox & Friends’ “Friendsgiving” series, opened with hosts Steve Doocy, Ainsley Earhardt, and Brian Kilmeade citing data from the American Farm Bureau Federation and Wells Fargo, which highlighted savings on staples like turkey (down 6%) and cranberries (down 23%). “This is good news – families can breathe a little easier,” Doocy said, nodding to President-elect Donald Trump’s recent claims of “falling food prices” under incoming policies. Earhardt added, “But polls show 58% of Americans still feel the pinch – is the relief real?” Enter Compagno, the 45-year-old legal analyst and co-host, who leaned into the mic with a twinkle in her eye: “I have a source who agrees with the optimism – Santa Claus told me there’s a high sense of optimism he hasn’t seen for a long time.”
The studio paused. Kilmeade burst out laughing: “Santa? Emily, what are you on?” Compagno, unfazed, doubled down: “I’m serious! He said the elves are buzzing – gift lists are up, and the North Pole’s feeling the holiday spirit more than in years.” Doocy, playing along, quipped, “Did he mention tariffs on reindeer feed?” The moment, light-hearted amid the economic talk, quickly went viral with 8.2 million views on X and TikTok, fans divided between “adorable holiday cheer” and “what just happened?”
Compagno later clarified on her Instagram Story: “It was a fun way to lighten the load – Santa’s optimistic because families are, too. Holidays bring hope!” The bit, inspired by a Wells Fargo note on consumer sentiment, highlighted the disconnect: while prices dip (gas down 12%, stuffing down 15%), 62% of Americans per NPR/PBS NewsHour polls feel financially worse off than pre-pandemic. Trump’s team touted the data as “proof of coming prosperity,” but critics like Sen. Elizabeth Warren called it “smoke and mirrors amid wage stagnation.”
The exchange underscores Fox & Friends’ blend of news and levity, a formula that’s boosted ratings 15% this quarter. As Thanksgiving feasts loom, Compagno’s Santa sighting – whimsical or weird – reminds us: in tough times, a dash of North Pole magic might be the real relief.
