In a stunning on-air revelation that has caught viewers and media insiders by surprise, Fox News announced that Sandra Smith will officially replace Jessica Tarlov on the network’s flagship panel show, The Five. The unexpected move was unveiled during a live segment when co-host Greg Gutfeld introduced Smith as his new permanent counterpart—marking a bold shake-up that’s already generating major buzz across conservative media circles.

The change signals not just a personnel swap, but a strategic recalibration of the show’s dynamic, tone, and political positioning. For fans of The Five, a program known for its lively debates and sharply contrasting viewpoints, the shift is being called “the most significant co-host change in years.”

A Live Reveal That Shocked Viewers

The news broke during what initially seemed like a routine Monday episode. Midway through the show, after a segment on border security, Greg Gutfeld casually turned to the camera and said, “Oh, and by the way—starting today, The Five has a new look. Please welcome Sandra Smith, who will be taking Jessica Tarlov’s seat moving forward.”

The announcement drew audible surprise from the live studio audience, and within minutes, social media exploded with reactions from both supporters and skeptics of the decision.

“This is the shake-up The Five needed,” tweeted one viewer.
“Wait… Sandra Smith replacing Jessica? That’s a massive shift in energy and tone,” wrote another.

Why the Change Happened

While Fox News has not released a formal statement about Tarlov’s departure from the show, sources inside the network cite a “strategic programming shift” driven by internal data and audience feedback. Jessica Tarlov, known for her progressive policy takes and frequent clashes with the show’s conservative majority, was often cast as The Five’s left-leaning voice—a role that, while necessary for the panel’s format, sometimes led to polarized responses from viewers.

Tarlov is reportedly transitioning into a new analyst role focused on special reports and digital platforms, though it’s unclear whether she will continue to appear regularly on-air.

Sandra Smith, by contrast, brings a blend of journalistic credibility, economic expertise, and a polished, center-right perspective that many insiders believe will broaden the show’s appeal.

“Sandra is sharp, informed, and calm under pressure,” said a former Fox producer. “Her presence will change the entire chemistry of the show—and probably bring a different kind of viewer into the mix.”

Greg Gutfeld’s Influence

There’s little doubt that Greg Gutfeld—The Five’s breakout star and ratings magnet—had a major role in the switch. Known for his edgy wit and dominant presence on the panel, Gutfeld has reportedly been pushing behind the scenes for a co-host who can “challenge the conversation without derailing it.”

Smith, who previously co-anchored America Reports, is seen as someone who can hold her ground with Gutfeld while keeping the discourse sharp but civil.

“Greg respects intelligence and timing,” said one insider. “Sandra has both—and she knows how to read the room.”

Fan Reactions: Mixed But Loud

Unsurprisingly, reactions to the shake-up have been passionate. Some fans who had grown tired of the frequent tension between Tarlov and the rest of the panel are welcoming the new era.

“No more shouting matches—just smart conversation,” said one Facebook user.

Others, however, are expressing concern that removing the sole progressive voice may hurt the show’s credibility as a space for balanced discussion.

“Love Sandra, but without Jessica, The Five risks becoming an echo chamber,” wrote one viewer on Reddit.

Still, Fox News appears to be betting big on the chemistry between Gutfeld and Smith, banking on the idea that their combined media savvy and sharp commentary will take the show to even higher ratings.

What’s Next for Jessica Tarlov?

Though she’s no longer a daily presence on The Five, Jessica Tarlov isn’t disappearing from Fox News. Reports suggest she’ll play a larger role in the network’s digital news expansion, including special interviews, podcasts, and weekend programming. Tarlov has yet to comment publicly on the change, though she reposted the announcement with a neutral message thanking her fans for their continued support.

A New Era Begins

As of now, Sandra Smith is already in the chair, and the first few episodes have shown a noticeably different energy. Segments that once dissolved into shouting have turned into pointed, controlled exchanges, and viewers are already noticing the shift.

Whether or not this gamble pays off for Fox News remains to be seen—but one thing is certain: The Five has entered a new chapter. And with Greg Gutfeld and Sandra Smith leading the charge, it’s going to be anything but boring.