Who’s In and Who’s Out? ‘Sullivan’s Crossing’ Season 4 Cast Shake-Up Has Fans Asking Tough Questions

Sullivan’s Crossing has quickly become one of the most emotionally resonant and binge-worthy dramas on television, but as the show gears up for its much-anticipated fourth season, a cloud of uncertainty looms over the future of some key characters—and the actors who play them.

After a rollercoaster of a third season, which aired its finale on July 16 on The CW and is headed to Netflix later this year, fans are not only buzzing about the cliffhangers but also concerned: Which cast members are returning for Season 4, and which might be leaving Sullivan’s Crossing behind for good?

Sources close to production have hinted at major changes, and some cast contracts reportedly expired after Season 3—leaving loyal viewers on edge.

Who’s Confirmed to Return?

Let’s start with the good news. The heart and soul of the series, Morgan Kohan, is officially signed on to reprise her role as Maggie Sullivan. As the show’s protagonist, Maggie remains central to the unfolding drama in Nova Scotia, and fans can expect her journey of healing, love, and rediscovery to continue in full force.

Alongside her, Scott Patterson is locked in to return as Sully, Maggie’s gruff but endearing father. After a season that explored his health struggles and deep emotional wounds, Sully’s story is far from over. Patterson is said to be “deeply invested” in Sully’s future arc.

Andrea Menard (Edna), Lynda Boyd (Phoebe), and Tom Jackson (Frank) are also expected to return, ensuring the community dynamic that gives Sullivan’s Crossing its heart remains intact.

Chad Michael Murray’s Uncertain Future

The biggest question mark heading into Season 4 is Chad Michael Murray, who plays Cal Jones—the reclusive newcomer with a complicated past and Maggie’s slow-burn love interest.

Murray, whose star power helped elevate the show in its early seasons, reportedly has a “flex option” in his contract for Season 4, and insiders say his return is not yet guaranteed. While there’s been no official statement from The CW or Murray’s reps, rumors are swirling that scheduling conflicts and creative direction may complicate his involvement.

Fans were quick to notice that Cal’s story ended on an ambiguous note in the Season 3 finale, with hints that he might be leaving Sullivan’s Crossing to face unfinished business elsewhere. While this could serve as a compelling plot device, it also raises fears that Murray may be written out or reduced to guest appearances.

“If Cal leaves, so do I,” one fan wrote on social media. “Maggie and Cal are the heart of the show!”

Allan Hawco’s Surprise Exit?

Another cast member who may not return is Allan Hawco, who plays Andrew Mathews—Maggie’s former fiancé and a lingering presence from her past life in Boston. While Andrew appeared sporadically in Season 3, his arc seemed to conclude with a sense of closure, and Hawco’s busy production schedule on other Canadian projects may keep him from returning.

“He was never meant to be a long-term fixture,” a source close to production noted. “But that doesn’t mean he’s gone forever.”

New Faces and Storylines Ahead

Despite the potential cast departures, Season 4 promises fresh faces and story expansions. Showrunner Roma Roth has hinted at new characters being introduced from Robyn Carr’s Sullivan’s Crossing novels that have yet to appear on screen.

“There’s a lot more to explore in this world,” Roth told fans during a recent panel. “New people, new challenges, and of course—more romance.”

There are also whispers of crossover potential with Carr’s other hit series, Virgin River, which exists in the same fictional universe. While nothing has been confirmed, the prospect of a shared storyline between Maggie and Virgin River’s Mel Monroe (Alexandra Breckenridge) has fans buzzing.

A Balancing Act for Season 4

As Sullivan’s Crossing enters its next chapter, the writers and producers face the delicate task of maintaining continuity while evolving the story. The absence of even one beloved character could shift the emotional dynamic of the show—but change also brings opportunity.

Whether Cal remains by Maggie’s side or exits for a time, the strength of Sullivan’s Crossing lies in its emotional authenticity, rich characters, and sense of community.

One thing is certain: fans will be watching closely.

As the cast and crew prepare to return to Nova Scotia for filming later this year, viewers can only hope their favorite characters—and actors—make the journey with them. Because in a place like Sullivan’s Crossing, everyone counts.