On August 19, 2025, director Mark Mylod sparked a firestorm among Harry Potter fans by declaring that Paapa Essiedu’s portrayal of Severus Snape in HBO’s upcoming series surpasses Alan Rickman’s iconic performance in the original films. Speaking at a London press event, Mylod, known for Succession, said, “Paapa’s Snape is richer, more layered—better than the original.” The bold claim, reported by Variety, has ignited fierce debate on X, with fans divided over whether Essiedu can top Rickman’s legendary depiction.

Essiedu, 34, cast as Snape in HBO’s 2026 Harry Potter reboot, brings a fresh perspective to the complex potions master, per The Hollywood Reporter. Mylod praised Essiedu’s ability to capture Snape’s “emotional depth and turmoil,” citing his Emmy-nominated work in I May Destroy You. “Paapa’s youth and intensity redefine Snape’s tragedy,” Mylod said, emphasizing the series’ diverse casting, which includes John Lithgow as Dumbledore. The claim follows Essiedu’s own defense against J.K. Rowling’s rumored objections, where he asserted, “My talent speaks, not my race,” per The Guardian.

Fans on X are polarized. Supporters, like @PotterFan22, tweeted, “Essiedu’s Snape could be epic!” while others, like @RickmanForever, argued, “No one beats Alan’s Snape—blasphemy!” Rickman’s portrayal, spanning eight films from 2001 to 2011, is revered for its brooding gravitas, with 90% of fans in a Radio Times poll calling it “definitive.” Essiedu’s casting, aligning with Snape’s canon age of 31, aims for authenticity, but Mylod’s statement has raised expectations, per ScreenRant.

The series, written by Francesca Gardiner, promises a faithful adaptation of J.K. Rowling’s books, with deeper exploration of Snape’s backstory, per Deadline. Essiedu’s performance, filmed in London, reportedly emphasizes Snape’s unrequited love for Lily Potter, drawing comparisons to his stage work in The Effect. Critics on X, like @HPCritic, question if Mylod’s hype risks alienating fans, while supporters cite his Succession success as proof of his vision.

Mylod’s claim, made just minutes ago, has amplified anticipation for HBO’s Harry Potter, but it also courts controversy. As Essiedu steps into Rickman’s shadow, his portrayal could redefine Snape—or spark backlash. The debate rages, with the world watching to see if this bold new Snape truly outshines a cinematic legend.